Partisan whipping forces through UDC approval of draft Local Plan

Uttlesford District CouncilIn a noisy, heated and often contentious meeting on 8th April the full Uttlesford District Council approved the draft of UDC Cabinet’s Local Plan by 23 votes to 14.

Already rejected by residents

Before the meeting the draft Local Plan had already been rejected by Uttlesford residents. 99% of public consultees objected to the draft in 2012 and again in December 2013 there was further overwhelming objection to the update; to all intents and purposes the latest draft of the Local Plan is the same, just with more houses.

The updated draft was still unsound because it was unsustainable and had unresolved issues with regard to traffic, jobs, education and water. It also breached legally required air quality levels, and the views of towns, parishes and the public were not properly considered.

These points were raised by a number of members of the public that spoke to oppose the plan, including (read our statement). There were no public speakers in support of the draft Local Plan.

Partisan Approval

The meeting had an nasty air to it all the way through. Residents were frustrated that they had been ignored for the last 2 years and major defects in the plan had not been addressed.  Those opposing the plan provided cogent reasons why the plan needed to be reworked, whist those supporting it just cited the need for more homes and that they believed that the plan was sound. As a result the UDC Cabinet seemed to be spoiling for a fight, being dismissive and throwing insults at both Liberal Democrats and residents alike. They even threatened to end local democracy by holding future meetings in private.

When it came to the vote there was balanced cross-party opposition to the plan with 6 Conservatives, 5 Liberal Democrats and all 3 Independents pushing for refusal. But it wasn’t enough to derail the party whipped majority Conservative group. No councillors from any other parties voted to approve the plan.

Unusually there were no abstentions. Interestingly it seemed that those on the fence stayed away, with 7 councillors choosing to be absent. An odd decision for what is probably one of the most significant votes of their district political career.

How did your councillor vote?

Do you want to know how your councillor represented you? 23 voted for approval and 14 were against approval of this draft of the Local Plan. See below.

Listen to the replay

UDC have now made repays of certain meeting available online. You can listen to this Council Meeting of 8th April 2014 on The public speakers are at the beginning before it moves to the full council debate. The chairman of the meeting was Cllr Eric Hicks.

What happens next

After the meeting, Dan Starr chair of said:

“The ruling UDC Cabinet has clearly lost touch with the residents of Uttlesford. Whilst a number of councillors from all parties made strong factual and emotional pleas for this unsound draft of the Local Plan to be rejected and fixed, the Cabinet instead chose to insult and be dismissive of residents. UDC Leader Jim Ketteridge summed up by lecturing the voters of Uttlesford that a public consultation wasn’t a referendum, and so UDC had the right to ignore their wishes. It may not be a referendum, but this old-school patronising attitude towards local government is likely to mean that the 2015 district council elections will be.”

This approved draft of the Local Plan will be available for a further round public consultation during the Spring of 2014 before being sent to the Planning Inspectorate for review over the Summer and Autumn. It will then be adopted by the UDC full council in early 2015.

However now that this draft is approved, UDC will seek to use it to green-light the building of 5,900 new homes on the remaining developers’ sites that the Council has been promoting across the district, including Saffron Walden, Great Dunmow, Elsenham and other settlements.

Tagged with: , , , , , , , ,
Posted in Education and Schools, News, Planning, Pollution and Air Quality, Spotlight Articles, Traffic, Uttlesford District Council, Uttlesford Local Plan, Water and Sewage
5 comments on “Partisan whipping forces through UDC approval of draft Local Plan
  1. Janet Harris says:

    Totally completely disgusted! The behaviour if those at the top leaves me shaking with anger! They don’t live ,will not be living with the destruction and upset and stress they will cause. They are ticking boxes and lining the councils coffers!

  2. Harry Cundell says:

    I am 90 years of age and was at the meeting. I have always been a conservative and I am a fairly new resident of Saffron Walden having lived in the Croydon Borough all my life. The voices opposing the Plan were very clear and the speakers did an excellent job, BUT public support, as always, has not been forthcoming. I feel that we are being conned by a dictatorship which rides roughshod over us but equally the inactivity by residents sitting on their backsides complaining and not joining your organisation is also alarming.
    I am totally disgusted by the attitude of the planners most of whom do not live in our beautiful town. We will have our revenge next year but they have done irreparable damage.

  3. Ray Franklin says:

    Although I understand the frustration which is apparent from Harry Cundell I must take issue with one thing he says. The “inactivity by residents sitting on the backsides would be inexcusable if it was not for one thing. I have been one of the people circulating consultation papers. I have spoken at Planning meetings. I have done what I consider is my bit. BUT we are all suffering from “Consultation fatigue,,” I realise to beat us down has been their wish. sadly people are fed up filling in loads of forms, Ray Franklin.

  4. Lynne Blount says:

    I am totally appalled by the attitude and arrogance of many of the councillors last night at the council meeting. I can honestly say I have never felt so patronised in my life! Who do they think they are, to speak to the us in that aggressive and contemptuous manner? They are there to serve! Do they think we are all stupid? I think the old adage about a small amount of power is being played out here. They are intent on ruining this town and our quality of life and my only consolation now, is that they will be remembered for having done so. There will be no local accolades for them in the future. I would suggest that some of them should be sent on a communication course that includes how to prevent your facial expression showing utter contempt for the general public and how to respond to people in a polite and sensitive manner.

    I would like to thank the councillors who spoke out against the plan and their obvious integrity. It can’t have been easy to go against the obvious bullying tactics of some of the other councillors. What a shambles!

  5. Angela Foster says:

    I am also totally disgusted that it has been approved. I have attended every public meeting except lat week, last one as a VERY serious family emergency called me many miles away. they should be ashamed of themselves

Comments are closed.

Is where you live on the map?
Feature: Local Plan Sites


Sign up for our email updates, follow us on your favourite sites or help us out:

Subscribe to email updates Follow on Facebook Follow on Twitter Volunteer to help us

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

%d bloggers like this: